by David J. Finch, Chad Saunders, Stephen Murgatroyd, Nadège Levallet, Norm O’Reilly, & Hussein Al-Zyoud






Governments have spent decades trying to make higher education more responsive. Performance-based funding, micro-credentials, work-integrated learning, and online delivery have all promised transformation. Yet institutions and credential structures have largely absorbed each of them.
The usual explanations point to rigid governance, cautious leadership, and conservative institutional cultures. These matter, but they cannot account for a pattern that repeats across systems and reform cycles.
In a forthcoming paper in Policy Reviews in Higher Education, we argue that the core question is not why institutions resist change, but why the system is structured to absorb it.
The bottleneck isn’t teaching. It’s recognition.
Our analysis draws on natural monopoly and contestability theory from the economics of regulated infrastructure. The claim isn’t that universities are monopoly firms, but that the focus should be on the shared infrastructure underpinning higher education and on who controls access to it.
That infrastructure has three functions:
- Validation: the authority to formally recognise learning and award credentials.
- Coordination: the rules that make credits and credentials portable across institutions and sectors.
- Signalling: the processes through which credentials become trusted indicators of capability in the labour market.
Learning happens in many settings, including bootcamps, employer academies, and online platforms. Without access to trusted recognition, however, these pathways lack the portability and credibility of established credentials, and alternative pathways struggle to scale.
The problem is most acute in publicly dependent systems, where most students attend publicly subsidised institutions and public authorities control much of recognition and quality assurance. Canada, the UK, the Nordic countries, and much of continental Europe fit this model.
Where the rigidity comes from
Five structural conditions hold the system in place:
- Concentrated validation infrastructure. Shared standards make credentials trustworthy, but authorised institutions and bodies control access to accreditation, assessment, and recognition, often favouring established models.
- Inelastic credential demand. Enrolment is less price-sensitive than expected, because learners need recognised credentials, not just access to learning.
- Vertical integration. Institutions typically design curricula, deliver instruction, assess learning, and award credentials, controlling the entire chain.
- Reputational asymmetry. Employers use institutional prestige to reduce hiring uncertainty. Rankings and funding reinforce established hierarchies.
- Concentrated signalling authority. Degrees remain the dominant hiring signal, even where they only partly reflect job-relevant capabilities.
The result is high barriers to entry, fragmented learning pathways, and innovations that are absorbed rather than scaled.
The consequences extend beyond universities. Adult and non-traditional learners struggle to have their learning recognised. Employers build their own assessments. Valuable learning from work, communities, and online platforms goes under-recognised.
In Canada, 21.8 per cent of core-aged workers with a postsecondary credential reported being overqualified for their job in 2025. Overqualification has many causes, but it raises questions about how well education translates into recognised labour-market value.
Lessons from other sectors
Telecommunications, utilities, rail, and banking have faced similar challenges. Their responses, including number portability, open banking, and separating infrastructure from service delivery, changed who could access essential systems.
The principle is clear: innovation depends not only on who provides a service, but also on who controls the infrastructure needed to participate.
For higher education, this suggests three policy interventions:
- Power redistribution: shifting resources and choice toward learners through portable entitlements, learner-directed funding, and transparent recognition rules.
- System unbundling: separating instruction from assessment and credential validation, so learning from different sources can earn comparable recognition.
- Ecosystem governance: establishing independent stewardship of credential registries, interoperability standards, and trusted signalling infrastructure.
Each carries risks. Choice without support can reinforce inequality. Unbundling without standards can fragment the system. Independent regulators can be captured.
We therefore propose governed contestability, in which open access to shared infrastructure, inclusive quality standards, independent public stewardship, and equity safeguards work together.
This is not an argument for privatisation or deregulation. It is about preserving public trust while allowing diverse learning pathways to earn recognition.
Case studies and policy lessons
Three policy cases illustrate these principles.
Across the European Higher Education Area, the Bologna Process and related recognition initiatives established common standards to reduce barriers to cross-border mobility. Implementation remains uneven, but the case shows that shared coordination infrastructure can improve portability without altering institutional missions.
New Zealand’s Qualifications Authority established a national micro-credential framework that lets universities, private trainers, and industry organisations gain formal recognition under shared quality standards. This illustrates partial unbundling supported by independent stewardship, though long-term employer acceptance remains uncertain.
England provides a contrast. Following the Browne Review, reforms expanded student choice and opened funding to alternative providers, but institutional control over degree recognition and signalling remained largely intact. Competition increased within the existing hierarchy rather than changing it.
These cases are illustrative rather than causal tests, but they point to a common lesson: expanding choice without reforming control over validation and signalling risks reproducing the existing system.
Policy implications
Governments favour pilots, micro-credentials, and performance funding partly because these can be introduced without redistributing authority, which may also explain their limited system-level impact.
The paper sets out five diagnostic expectations, with measurable indicators, for distinguishing structural reform from institutional adaptation. Three questions capture their spirit: Are learners losing credits when transferring? Can alternative providers obtain recognition? Do employers trust alternative credentials?
The answers reveal whether reform changes the system’s architecture or adds programmes within it.
Universities do far more than award credentials. They advance research, preserve knowledge, and strengthen communities. This argument does not diminish those contributions; it separates their public value from their cManuscriptontrol over the infrastructure that recognises learning.
The aim is not to weaken universities, but to ensure that high-quality learning is recognised wherever and however it occurs, while protecting trust and equity.
For higher education reform to succeed, policy must tackle the bottleneck in recognition infrastructure rather than expect institutions to innovate around it.
David J. Finch is Professor of Innovation and Marketing at Mount Royal University and Visiting Fellow at Henley Business School. His research examines education, labour markets, human capital, and the relationship between learning, workforce development, and productivity.
Chad Saunders is a Professor at the University of Calgary’s Haskayne School of Business. His research examines entrepreneurship, innovation, organisational change, and higher education governance, with particular emphasis on the institutional conditions that shape adaptation and transformation.
Stephen Murgatroyd teaches anticipatory studies at the University of Alberta and Athabasca University. He has authored more than 40 books and delivers keynote presentations internationally on artificial intelligence, education, organisational transformation, and the future of work.
Nadège Levallet is an Associate Professor at the University of Maine and holds a PhD in Management Information Systems from Queen’s University. Her research examines digital technologies and organisational discontinuity, including their implications for institutional adaptation, human capital, and productivity.
Norm O’Reilly is Professor of Sport Management and Director of The Sponsorship Lab at the University of Florida. Internationally recognised for his scholarship, he researches the business of sport, with particular expertise in sponsorship and sport management.
Hussein Al-Zyoud is Associate Professor of Economics at Athabasca University, specialising in labour and international economics. His research examines income inequality, gender wage disparities, and the economic and human-capital factors that shape labour market outcomes in Canada.
